Top 10 Oscar-nominated Movies With No Wins

by Alan Rapp on February 24, 2009

in Top 10s

Contributor Alan Rapp offers this surprising list up for today. If you have your own idea for a Top 10 list, email

It’s just an honor to be nominated… Is it really? You’ve heard that expression for years. Let’s face it, the Academy Awards snubs many a film when it posts its nominations. Almost as bad, or in some occasions perhaps worse, is to be nominated for multiple Oscars only to take home none. Hmm… I wonder if someone could create a list of such films. Oh wait, someone just did!

There are actually more films that fit into this category than you might first think. I’ve managed to squeeze 11 onto the list but others also worthy of note include “The Grifters,” “Being John Malkovich,” “The Natural,” “Pride & Prejudice,” and–still my favorite Paul Thomas Anderson film–”Magnolia.” That’s what didn’t make the cut. Now check out what did.

10. The Magnificent Seven (1960) / The Great Escape (1963)

The Great EscapeWe start out with a pair of films which both only earned a single nomination each, neither taking home the award. One was based on a book, the other was adapted from a Japanese film (which, by the way, also didn’t take home an Oscar). Looking back, you would think that at least one would have won for score (“Great Escape” wasn’t even nominated in that category!), but alas the Academy had other plans. Whether it’s a gang of seven (Yul Brynner, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, Robert Vaughn, Horst Buchholz, among others) rescuing a small Mexican town or a group of P.O.W.s (James, Garner, Richard Attenborough, and again Bronson, Coburn, and McQueen) attempting to escape from a Nazi camp, both movies long ago earned the mantle of “classic.” A little McQueen trivia for you: The actor crashed his car to be able to free up time while “injured” to work on “Magnificent Seven,” and performed most of his own motorcycle stunts (including the unique move of “chasing himself” in a double stunt as the hero and also disguised as his a German officer in pursuit) in “Great Escape.”

Chico: “Ah, that was the greatest shot I’ve ever seen.”
Britt: “The worst! I was aiming at the horse.”

9. The Player (1992)

The PlayerI have some mixed feelings about Robert Altman’s tale of a blackmailed Hollywood exec (Tim Robbins) and his slow descent into paranoia, insanity, and murder. At times it’s utterly brilliant, but I do find the structure of the murder storyline takes over a little too much, getting  away from the bitter satire of how Hollywood makes movies. The film earned nominations for directing, editing, and screenplay, but Clint Eastwood put out a little movie that year called “Unforgiven” and “The Player” went home empty-handed.

Griffin Mill: “I was just thinking what an interesting concept it is to eliminate the writer from the artistic process. If we could just get rid of these actors and directors, maybe we’ve got something here.”

8. Hoosiers (1986)

HoosiersChances are if you love sports movies–particularly basketball ones–this film will rank near your favorites of the genre. Putting aside the first “Rocky” for the moment, here is the quintessential underdog-makes-good sports tale. Although it did earn nominations for original score and Dennis Hopper, in a supporting role as an alcoholic assistant coach, Gene Hackman’s starring role (Jack Nicholson was originally cast, but had to remove himself because of a scheduling conflict) as the volatile coach getting a second chance was ignored. Over the past two decades, many sports films have tried to recapture the film’s magic but few have had its simplicity, charm, and spirit.

Coach Norman Dale: “Welcome to Indiana basketball.”

7. Frost/Nixon (2008)

Frost NixonThis is the film that spurred the creation of this list. Nominated for five Oscars (for picture, actor, director, screenplay, and editing), “Frost/Nixon” is my favorite Ron Howard film in some time and my choice for best film of 2008. Inspired by the play of the same name, Richard Nixon (Best Actor nominee Frank Langella) is brought down by the most unlikely of knights, a British talk-show host (Michael Sheen) with no political affiliations or agenda. The film hearkens back to one of America’s darkest political eras, and is timely as well, given our former President’s actions in office.

David Frost: “Are you really saying the President can do something illegal?”
Richard Nixon: “I’m saying that when the President does it, that means it’s not illegal!”

6. The Verdict (1982)

The VerdictTwo words – Paul Newman. Nominated for five Oscars (Newman, Supporting Actor nominee James Mason, Director Sidney Lumet, picture, and screenplay), this courtroom drama had the same number of statues after the show as it did before. With strong competition from the likes of “Gandhi,” “E.T.,” and Dustin Hoffman in “Tootsie” (Damn, 1982 was a good year!), the film simply got squeezed out on Oscar night. If you’ve never seen it, rent it. And if you’ve got a copy on DVD, and some free time on your hands, you might want to keep an eye out for uncredited extras Bruce Willis and Tobin Bell.

Frank Galvin: “He’s a good man…”
Mickey Morrissey: “He’s a good man? Heh, heh, he’s the Prince of fucking Darkness! He’ll have people testifying they saw her water-skiing in Marblehead last summer. Now look, Frank, don’t fuck with this case!”

5. Munich (2005)

Munich2005 was a damn fine year for film. (You’ll find another from this crop down the list.) Steven Spielberg’s take on the aftermath of the killings at the 1972 Munich Olympics follows a band of Israeli assassins (Eric Bana, Daniel Craig, Ciaran Hinds, Matthieu Kassovitz, and Hans Zischler) who are put together to strike back at the terrorists responsible. Like the others on this list, the film took home none of the Oscars for which it was nominated (picture, director, screenplay, score, and editing–yet not a single acting nom!). “Munich” is a punch in the stomach that takes a hard look at terrorism and vengeance and the corrupting effects of both on good people.

Robert: “We are supposed to be righteous. That’s a beautiful thing. And we’re losing it. If I lose that, that’s everything. That’s my soul.”

4. North by Northwest (1959)

North by NorthwestEveryone has their favorite Hitchcock film. This is mine. Although the film current ranks #28 on IMDb’s top 250-rated films and earned a spot on AFI’s Top 100 Films, on Oscar night it went unrecognized, unable to win in the three categories (editing, art direction, and screenplay) in which it was nominated. Some films are great. Some films are filled with great moments. “North by Northwest” is both. From the insanity of the situation, Roger Thornhill (Cary Grant) finds himself in to the iconic images of running from the crop duster and climbing around Mt. Rushmore, this one’s got it all: suspense, humor, thrills, drama, and romance with the beautiful Eva Marie Saint. The film was also the inspiration for my favorite Gene Wilder/Richard Pryor team-up. It also an example of my “movies with trains theory,” but that’s another list. (I’ll explain that in the comments below if anyone is curious.)

Roger Thornhill: “Now you listen to me, I’m an advertising man, not a red herring. I’ve got a job, a secretary, a mother, two ex-wives and several bartenders that depend upon me, and I don’t intend to disappoint them all by getting myself slightly killed.”

3. Good Night, and Good Luck (2005)

Good Night and Good LuckI loved this movie enough to list it #1 on my Top Films of 2005, which was a strong year which included the aforementioned “Munich.” Although the film garnered some love by earning itself six nominations (including cinematography, screenplay, picture, director for George Clooney, and actor for David Strathairn), at the end of the night, “Good Luck” went home empty-handed. Every choice in this film is the right one, including the look and style of the film and the choice to use archival footage of Sen. Joseph McCarthy rather than cast an actor for the role. Clooney’s brilliant masterpiece was the best film of 2005, and centered around the historic battle of wills between journalist Edward R. Murrow (Strathairn) and McCarthy at the height of the Red Scare. It was also timely for a world with growing concern about an individual’s basic rights to privacy, and it served as an indictment and warning to a generation growing up in the current, dumbed-down TV culture.

Edward R. Murrow: “But even if they are right, what have they got to lose? Because if they are right, and this instrument is good for nothing but to entertain, amuse and insulate, then the tube is flickering now and we will soon see that the whole struggle is lost. This instrument can teach, it can illuminate; yes, and it can even inspire. But it can do so only to the extent that humans are determined to use it to those ends. Otherwise it is merely wires and lights in a box.”

2. The Color Purple (1985)

The Color PurpleIt’s not the best movie on the list, but it’s by far the most snubbed. I’m not one to argue that this is Steven Spielberg’s best film, but 11 nominations and not a single win? Really? Only one other film in Oscar history shares that honor. Although many critics chose it as the best movie of the year, the film wasn’t without controversy because some in the African-American community argued passionately against Spielberg being the right choice to helm the project, based on a novel about an abused black woman in the first half of the 20th century. Although Whoopi would eventually go on to grab an Oscar by talking to Patrick Swayze’s “Ghost,” the film itself received no love from the Academy on its special night, going a whopping 0 for 11.

Shug: “I think it pisses God off when you walk by the color purple in a field and don’t notice it.”

1. Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (1964)

Dr. StrangeloveWow. Four nominations (Peter Sellers, picture, director, and screenplay) and not a single win. Wow. No matter how many different ways I put together my favorite ten films ever made, Stanley Kubrick’s satire on nuclear war always finds its way near the top. Peter Sellers is so good in three separate performances that my favorite one changes from viewing to viewing. George C. Scott displays tremendous comic timing, Slim Pickens plays it straight (he wasn’t told the film was a comedy) and Sterling Hayden teaches us all about the terrors of flouridation (the horror!). Simply put, “Dr. Strangelove” was way ahead of its time. Had this movie been made today, it would be appreciated in a different light completely.

President Merkin Muffley: “General Turgidson, I find this very difficult to understand. I was under the impression that I was the only one in authority to order the use of nuclear weapons.”
General “Buck” Turgidson: “That’s right, sir, you are the only person authorized to do so. And although I, uh, hate to judge before all the facts are in, it’s beginning to look like, uh, General Ripper exceeded his authority.”

A stalwart fan of under-appreciated cinematic gems such as Condorman, Alan Rapp has harangued, belittled, and argued with just about every Scene-Stealers contributor ever. More of his insight, comic nerdiness, and righteous fury can be found at dadsbigplan, RazorFine Review, and ‘Xplosion of Awesome, and the Four Color Freak-Out podcast.

Facebook Twitter Google+ 

{ 17 comments… read them below or add one }

1 hellohawk February 24, 2009 at 5:23 pm

Nice list! I like the murder subplot of the Player, though. After all, it itself is the movie that is made from what actually happened, so the Hollywood way has to be represented somehow.

Seriously, is there any other movie where one actor does THREE performances as good as Sellers in Strangelove? I think not. There’s hardly a movie with an actor that does ONE performance as good as any of the three!


2 Reed February 24, 2009 at 10:27 pm

Great list! And a great idea for a list! I’d like to add nominations for:
12 Angry Men
21 Grams
Blade Runner
Breaking the Waves
Children of Men
Double Indemnity (7 nominations, no wins)
Hoop Dreams (nominated for editing, not best doc – no idea why)
Hotel Rwanda
Mulholland Dr.
Running on Empty
Secrets & Lies (shut out despite 5 nominations)
The Wrestler


3 Alan Rapp February 25, 2009 at 9:21 am

Nice list Reed. I left off the Wrestler since I already had something from this past year, and two from just a couple years ago, and didn’t want to overload the list with recent films. As I worked up the list I also tried to stay away from films with just one or two noms as much as I could. I hadn’t really thought of Blade Runner or Children of Men but they are interesting picks. Double Indemnity is so good it should have been one of mine.


4 Will February 25, 2009 at 2:58 pm

good list, however you did leave out:
Rear Window
A Clockwork Orange
Citizen Kane (although it did win Best Screenplay)


5 Alan Rapp February 25, 2009 at 4:46 pm

Will, I chose North by Northwest over Rear Window rather than including them both, though thinking about it maybe I should have put them both together, like I did for #10. Oh well. Clockwork Orange is a great movie but given its level of violence I’m not in the least surprised the Academy of that era flinched from handing it an Oscar. And, as you point out, Citizen Kane doesn’t fit on the list.


6 Shaun February 28, 2009 at 12:58 pm

Tell us about the trains, please, Alan?


7 Kenny March 4, 2009 at 5:17 pm

Yours and Reed’s combined lists contain some of my all time faves! It just goes to show that the Academy doesn’t know everything and that great films really transcend awards, lists and other quantitative measurements.


8 Alan Rapp March 5, 2009 at 12:34 pm

“Tell us about the trains, please, Alan?”

You might say my train theory is still in the experimental stage, needing refinement, but, in a nutshell, it’s this:

All things being equal, movies with trains are better than movies without trains.

That’s not to say the worst movie with a train is better than the best without. What I mean is if you take two similar films, one with a train and one without, usually (not always, there are exceptions) the one with the train will be, at least slightly, superior to the one without a train.


9 Racine Oxtoby March 12, 2009 at 1:15 pm

Where’s the Shawshank Redemption? It was nominated for seven awards (including Best Picture) and didn’t win a single one. Meanwhile, today it sits at the top of IMDb’s Top 250 List.


10 Alan Rapp March 23, 2009 at 1:50 pm

I didn’t forget about it; it was purposefully left off the list.


11 Claudia October 3, 2009 at 4:42 pm

Shawshank Redemption is my absolutely favorite movie. It was totally robbed by Forrest Gump.


12 FDX April 6, 2010 at 10:16 am

“I didn’t forget about it; it was purposefully left off the list.”

Can you explain why? Is is because it would have been too much of a cliché to add it yet again? Or do you seriously think it did not deserve any of the awards it was nominated for?


13 Stig April 29, 2010 at 10:03 am

Shawshank wouldn’t have beaten Forrest. Pulp Fiction was Forrest’s biggest threat


14 Jezza August 29, 2010 at 7:54 am

Another movie to consider: Transformers

Was considered the no brainer frontrunner in Visual Effects!

The Golden Compass pulled off a huge upset that year.

Funny fact:

The Golden Compass 1 Dr Strangelove 0


15 Eric Melin August 29, 2010 at 11:44 pm

Jezza- That’s a really good point. For visual effects that year, nothing could top Transformers. I think the blowback from the juvenile POV of the film is what really killed it that year. (The effects in Compass were mixed at best!)

Not-so-funny fact:

The Golden Compass 1 Dr Strangelove 0


16 Jezza August 31, 2010 at 3:56 pm

Eric- I’ll probably upset you now because I liked The Golden Compass. I admit that it’s relationship to the literary source is let’s say at best passing, but I enjoyed it nonetheless as a fun fantasy adventure.

By contrast I have always been disapointed with Dr Strangelove.

As for The Golden Compass’ “shock” win against Transformers, it may have been a case of the freshest memory influencing the vote.


17 Jezza September 1, 2010 at 2:52 am

I think if the Academy wants to reward films with thrills and suspence they will do so in fantasy form.

Here’s the proof

The Golden Compass 1 North by Northwest 0
Pirates of the Carribean: Dead Man’s Chest 1 Rear Window 0
Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion the Witch & the Wardrobe 1 Psyco 0


Leave a Comment


Previous post:

Next post: